Menu Icon Search
Close Search

Not So Common Interview Pitfalls

Created January 17, 2010 by Dr. Jessica Freedman
Share Comment

 

Some pitfalls of the medical school interview are obvious: Don’t ramble, don’t say “um” too much, don’t be rude to people, don’t chew gum and don’t greet your interviewer like this: “Hey Dave. It is great to meet you. I read everything I could find about you on the internet.” But what pitfalls might not be so obvious?

Not being prepared
You studied for the MCAT. You composed multiple drafts of your personal statement. So, why is it that you think walking in cold to your first medical school interview is acceptable? I find that many outstanding medical school applicants who have an impressive list of accomplishments are often not able to clearly articulate their motivations and paths to pursue a career in medicine. All great performances require practice, and speaking about yourself and essentially marketing your candidacy is not easy. So, practice, practice, practice. Most undergraduate career centers offer mock interviews. Or you can grab a friend, teacher, parent or relative who has more experience than you do in this arena. Practicing also builds confidence, which helps your performance.

Overpracticing
On the opposite side of the coin, practicing too much can also hurt you. Why? First of all, you don’t want your answers to sound rehearsed or canned. Ideally, you want your medical school interview to be conversational so if you are fixated on what you have rehearsed, a conversation pattern for which you didn’t prepare can make you overly anxious. In the same way, over-rehearsed applicants often stumble when they receive a question they weren’t anticipating.  This is also an issue for the fortunate applicant who has multiple interviewers. Try to keep your answers fresh, which can be challenging after being asked “Why do you want to be a doctor” for the 17th time.

Getting psyched out before the interview
“Everyone there already had at least 5 acceptances.” “I was the only one at the interview from a non-Ivy League school. I have no chance.” Sometimes the interactions between candidates as they wait for their interviewer or a presentation about the school can be harmful. Obviously, you don’t want to seem like a social outcast and sit alone in a corner of the conference room while the other applicants are chatting. But at the same time, you don’t want these casual conversations to cause you unnecessary anxiety before you enter your interviewer’s office.  Though it’s tough, try to stay away from, “So, where else have you interviewed/been accepted” type of topics. And, if such questions do arise, answer vaguely or change the topic without being rude. If you were invited for an interview, you are just as qualified as everyone else sitting in that room with you, and each interview is an opportunity for acceptance.

Adhering to strict rules
I heard I should speak only for a maximum of three minutes per answer.” “I heard that I need to ask my interviewer at least three questions to seem interested in the school.” Many myths are out there about what you “must do” or “not do” on interviews. Remember that your interviewers are not robots; they are individuals. The vast majority of interviews are not scripted so the rhythm and flow of an interview will depend on many factors, including your interviewer’s style, level of experience and even his or her mood that day. It is important to enter each interview with an open mind as to how the interview might progress. For example, some less-experienced interviewers may feel uncomfortable having a fluid conversation whereas the more experienced medical educator might purposefully get off topic and start a conversation about something in your background that you didn’t expect.

Telling them what they want to hear
It is important to research your school before your interview so you have a clear idea of its mission and values. You also want to try and tailor your answers so you fit these ideals as best you can. But the applicant who says something that is not sincere or that is inconsistent with her background has fallen right into a major pitfall. For example, the school that values community service is seeking students who have a demonstrated commitment in this area but also wants students who have other interests. When an applicant who has no background in community service says that she hopes to become involved in helping the underserved during medical school, her assertion seems patently false. Be true to yourself and make sure that everything you say is consistent with your background and experiences.

Trying too hard to “stand out” or “be distinctive.”
Applicants are always concerned about standing out from the crowd. “What can I say that will make me different than everyone else?” “What can I do that will be unique?” First of all, you cannot change who you are on your medical school interview day. Most interviews are somewhat biographical so your experiences are what they are. I find that when applicants try too hard to be “different,” they often undermine their own success.  Medical schools are not evaluating you on your distinctiveness, per se; they are trying to assess your motivation for a career in medicine, intelligence, communication skills and level of compassion, among other qualities. Sure, candidates who have accomplished something truly unusual are evaluated differently, but these candidates are the exception. Ironically, applicants who exude confidence, enthusiasm and authenticity and who are “comfortable in their own skin” are often the individuals who stand out. So, be yourself. A seasoned interviewer can sniff out insincerity. Trying to be someone or something that you are not will inevitably negatively impact your performance and your interviewer’s evaluation.

 

Ultimately, every interview dynamic is affected by the rapport between the interviewer and applicant, the interviewer’s approach and the applicant’s comfort level in speaking about himself, his motivations and his ideals. Be aware of the common pitfalls and be able to express who you are, why you want to pursue a career in medicine and how you got there.

Jessica Freedman, MD, a former medical admissions officer, is president of MedEdits, a medical school, residency and fellowship admissions consulting firm. She is also the author of the MedEdits blog and The Medical School Interview: From Preparation to Thank You Notes.

// Share //

// Comments //

Comments

  1. MedMan says:

    I also think it’s important to realize there are interviewers out there who are going to actually *try* to get you to lose your cool. Those types will typically ask questions that they know there is a good chance you won’t have the answer right off hand just to see how you’ll react. I think the best advice in a scenario like that is to just keep calm and don’t let yourself become flustered over a stupid question.

  2. Allison says:

    I am so excited about the interview process!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  3. MedN00b says:

    Hi Dr. Freedman,
    Great genuine advice. I always hear from health profession advisors that you do not want to tell interviewers what they want to hear. However, you touch on the significance of conveying yourself to your interviewers, while staying consistent. I have some questions for you though about the confidence one should have. I always hear doctors say, one of the good qualities include confidence, but not arrogance. I find this very difficult to do because during any interview process, you have to sell yourself and therefore some arrogance will be observable.
    1) Do you have any approach on the quality of being confident, but showing arrogance?
    Also, I noticed in the article that you didn’t touch on the phrase “I don’t know,” to questions you don’t know how to answer. Personally, I find this the most important phrase in every day life. My philosophy is if you are unsure of something, add I think; or if you don’t know the answer outright, just say, “I don’t know.” Don’t teach people the wrong information. If I want to learn something from someone, I would want them to tell me 100% accuracy of the fact. I’ve been through the experience where I would tell other people what I was told from my friend who told me the “fact,” and other people would correct me. So doesn’t that make me more idiotic than if my friend were to say earlier that he didn’t know? I’m sure the “I don’t know” is all relative to the situation.
    2)So what’s the reasoning behind the “I don’t know” phrase?
    Thanks,
    MedN00b

  4. aini says:

    I’m very nervous when thinking about my career, optometry…… I’s really unbelievable about what I really want to be…

  5. ann says:

    Thank you for posting such useful informations! I haven’t thought about a lot of them.

// Recent Articles //

Web
  • Graduation Day Thoughts on Student Debt

  • Posted July 6, 2015 by Atul Grover, M.D., Ph.D. AAMC Chief Public Policy Officer
  • Memorial Day and Mother’s Day are May’s official holidays, but for millions, graduation day is May’s biggest celebration—as momentous as a wedding or birth. Graduation creates memories of a proud family gathering, celebrations with classmates, and the inspiring message from a charismatic commencement speaker. I’ve had my share of graduations—high school, college at Cornell University,...VIEW >
IOTW-SDN small
  • Figure 1 Image of the Week, 7/4/15

  • Posted July 4, 2015 by Figure 1
  • Image of the Week – Treating Severe Varicose Veins This patient presents with a severe case of reflux-induced varicose veins. He is asymptomatic, active, and at a healthy weight. Which treatment is most appropriate? Find out on Figure 1....VIEW >
20150703_Cheat_SS_92769076
  • Medical, +1 MORE
  • Ensuring Fairness: An Interview with the Director of MCAT Security and Compliance

  • Posted July 3, 2015 by Student Doctor Network
  • Accuracy and fairness in scoring the MCAT exam is an essential part of the test’s role as an indicator of future medical school success. The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) requires all test-takers to sign an Examinee Agreement, promising to refrain from cheating or other compromises of the test. The agreement ensures that all...VIEW >
MattMcCarthyNinaSubin
  • Q&A With Physician-Author Matt McCarthy, MD

  • Posted June 29, 2015 by Chivas Owle
  • 1.  What specifically prompted you to write The Real Doctor Will See You Shortly? I was having dinner with my editor three years ago, and he asked if I’d ever thought of writing a book about medicine. I had kept a journal during my intern year, but I was hesitant to write about my experiences. Some were...VIEW >
IOTW-SDN small
  • Figure 1 Image of the Week, 6/27/15

  • Posted June 27, 2015 by Figure 1
  • Image of the Week: An unusual rash covering 90% body surface area. This patient had a biopsy that revealed erythema multiforme one month ago. Now, the patient returns with intact annular lesions covering 90% of his body. Do you think this is truly erythema multiforme or something more severe? Find out on Figure 1.  ...VIEW >
20150626_Stethoscope_SS_117670699
  • Medical, +1 MORE
  • 5 Reasons Intern Year is Better Than Medical School

  • Posted June 26, 2015 by Megan Riddle, MD PhD
  • I had a certain level of (I thought well-justified) terror anticipating the start of intern year. No longer able to hide behind the protective “I’m just the medical student” blockade, I was worried about not being able to live up to the burden and the privilege of being someone’s doctor. Third year was rough and...VIEW >

// Forums //