jmgt said:
hey all, just wondering what you guys think if i mentioned a depression/suicide attempt and overcoming it years ago in my secondaries. would adcoms not like that? its for the "tell us about a personal adversity/tragedy and how you coped" type questions.
would the frown on that?
thanks in advance alls
Hi there,
I serve on an admissions committee and as an advisor to the Dean of Students at two medical schools. I would advise you NOT to mention a suicide attempt in your secondary application especially if you did not mention it in your personal statement. If you did mention it in your personal statement, there is little that you can do at this point.
You could mention that you suffered a life-threatening illness (which is very true) and that going through that process made you stronger. I would leave out the details and explain your emotional reaction, how you overcame your illness (again do not be specific) and how you have used that adversity to spur yourself on to higher achievements.
At one of my medical schools, one of the students committed suicide during his freshman year. He was near the top of his class but obviously having a great deal of pain that he did not share with anyone. It profoundly affected several of his classmates with two having to take a leave of absence.
This being said, I would say that a past suicide attempt could end up being a very negative factor in terms of your application. It's not fair that you should bear a stigma because you have overcome your depression but do you want to take a chance with this?
Other than the above, I am at a loss as to how you can spin this so that it would be a positive instead of a negative. Medical school administrations are very "gun shy" when it comes to mental illness and sad to say, most of the folks who will be making the decision as to whether to admit you or not admit you are not clinical physicians like myself but Ph.Ds who can be rather narrow-minded.
Good luck and I am happy that you have survived. You will be an asset to your patients with this background.
njbmd