- Joined
- Sep 13, 2002
- Messages
- 1,692
- Reaction score
- 5
I will try my best to go thru each specialty on the match list and explain why things are the way they are. Furthermore, I think it should be highlighted that Northwestern has one of the better internal medicine programs in the nation. I would argue that UofC and Northwestern are on par with each other in the city of Chicago; both being world-class. Northwestern IS a more prestigious institution so why leave? Also, Chicago is a GREAT city. Many people have chosen to stay here on their own accord. People bring up places like Vandy...well...shoot, would YOU want to stay in tennessee? Also keep in mind...as a premed, its tough to tell which are the respectable/great programs in a given specialty. It is no longer based on whether or not it is affiliated with Harvard when you get to the residency level.
Internal Medicine
Actually, the numbers of kids from northwestern going into internal medicine was down for my class. The reason, being was that they worked my class real hard on IM. We learned a lot but also got pushed very very hard(in terms of hours worked...you would be surprised how that can shade students into going or not going into a specialty). Do not worry though, we bitched and moaned and the current 3rd year class is having a much, much easier time(and probably still learning as much as my class)
First, lets talk about who DID NOT match at northwestern. Notice, there are 2 kids going to UCSF. While UCSF is not east coast, it is the hopkins/mass general of the west coast. Frankly, I think San Francisco is a better city than Boston. However, the point being, those 2 kids could have easily went to Boston should they have chosen to do so. Then, there is Susan Pasnick, who did indeed choose to go to Harvard(Brigham and Women's). We also had one guy go to Cornell. This guy interviewed at all the best west coast AND east coast programs. Ultimately he ranked cornell as his highest east coast program because it was a very cush/respected program and he liked it the best(yes, even over mass general...gasp). Baylor has an excellent IM program, we sent 2 there. The rest are at great places(albeit not mass gen level, but very good nevertheless).
As for all the kids who matched at Northwestern for IM, again northwestern's IM program is world-class. With that said, 90% of the people who stayed at Northwestern were fully capable of going to Boston(or anywhere else for that matter). They had both the board scores and the grades and the charisma to go wherever they wanted. Some of them have family here and chose to stay. There were several who interviewed at the Boston programs but ultimately decided that it was not worth the move to Boston. I actually disagree with one of them who applied to mass gen for "poops and giggles." This person went to the interview for "poops and giggles" without any real intention of ranking mass gen in their top 3(i think that sucks for other applicants who really want to go there, but thats just me). The point being, most of the ones that chose to stay at northwestern could also go anywhere in the nation as well.
Pediatrics
Well, realize that we rotate thru Children's Memorial Hospital. CMH is one of the best children's hospitals in the country. So a lot of people chose to stay because of that. In fact, the people who ended up at UofC likely ranked CMH higher. The problem, CMH has this rule that they only take like 3 northwestern kids every year. In fact, this year our students were so good, they took more than the typical 3.
OB/Gyn
This is my specialty. Prentice Women's hospital is one of the best OB/Gyn programs in the nation. The girl who matched into it, could have gone anywhere in the nation. She did indeed check out the Boston programs as well as UNC and the other top tier OB programs, but she is from chicago, AND our OB/gyn program is is one of the best. (no lie) go through the faculty, all of the heads have pages and pages of publications. The rest all matched at great OB programs. UCSF, Wash U. The guy going to yale is interested in Gyn-Onc and Yale has one of the best gyn-onc programs.
Prelim and transitional years are BS. Don't even look at those lists. People pick based on where they will have the most "chill" year.
Psychiatry
We sent kids into two of the top psych programs in the nation(NYU and columbia). Actually, steph was so great a student, she would have matched well in any specialty she chose. Word on the street, is that the New York programs are the best. Theres a lot of crazies there!
Emergency Medicine
Hmm...I dont know aything about the competitiveness of the EM places other than cook county is great. I do know, that we usually send a steady stream of people to cook County(THE buesiest ER in the nation and the basis for tv's ER). This year we only sent 1, but the year before we sent like 3.
Orthopedics
These guys matched really well. Many of them stayed at Northwestern because its a good program. The ones that did not stay went to better programs. UWash is generally thought of as one of the best ortho progs in the nation, if not the best. HSS is also top tier, but very few people know about it outside of ortho because again, it does not have harvard or anything attached to its name.
General Surgery
This was probably our weakest specialty this year. They did not match at bad programs. However, admittedly, none of these places are Mass gen. Joe phillips probably could have gone to one of those places, however, he has family in chicago and is married so he chose to stay in the city.
Radiology
We have the best radiology program in the city(one can argue that UofC is on par with us). U maryland is also one of the best rads progs in the nation. Butler, interviewed all over the place and eventually decided on UTSW(another top tier rads program). He has family in texas.
I am tired of typing...I will talk about the other specialties later. I will also talk about those that did not match, and why they did not match.
In any case...I think our match list is great this year. Keep in mind, the quality of a school lies in whether it can take you where you want to go. Do not judge our list based on whether we have X amount of mass gen matches. Because I would argue that this year we had quite a few people want to stay in chicago. Many of those people could have, had they wanted to, go to hopkins, mass gen, etc. Nevertheless, our school provides that opportunity.
I shall write about the other specialties later. whew!
Internal Medicine
Actually, the numbers of kids from northwestern going into internal medicine was down for my class. The reason, being was that they worked my class real hard on IM. We learned a lot but also got pushed very very hard(in terms of hours worked...you would be surprised how that can shade students into going or not going into a specialty). Do not worry though, we bitched and moaned and the current 3rd year class is having a much, much easier time(and probably still learning as much as my class)
First, lets talk about who DID NOT match at northwestern. Notice, there are 2 kids going to UCSF. While UCSF is not east coast, it is the hopkins/mass general of the west coast. Frankly, I think San Francisco is a better city than Boston. However, the point being, those 2 kids could have easily went to Boston should they have chosen to do so. Then, there is Susan Pasnick, who did indeed choose to go to Harvard(Brigham and Women's). We also had one guy go to Cornell. This guy interviewed at all the best west coast AND east coast programs. Ultimately he ranked cornell as his highest east coast program because it was a very cush/respected program and he liked it the best(yes, even over mass general...gasp). Baylor has an excellent IM program, we sent 2 there. The rest are at great places(albeit not mass gen level, but very good nevertheless).
As for all the kids who matched at Northwestern for IM, again northwestern's IM program is world-class. With that said, 90% of the people who stayed at Northwestern were fully capable of going to Boston(or anywhere else for that matter). They had both the board scores and the grades and the charisma to go wherever they wanted. Some of them have family here and chose to stay. There were several who interviewed at the Boston programs but ultimately decided that it was not worth the move to Boston. I actually disagree with one of them who applied to mass gen for "poops and giggles." This person went to the interview for "poops and giggles" without any real intention of ranking mass gen in their top 3(i think that sucks for other applicants who really want to go there, but thats just me). The point being, most of the ones that chose to stay at northwestern could also go anywhere in the nation as well.
Pediatrics
Well, realize that we rotate thru Children's Memorial Hospital. CMH is one of the best children's hospitals in the country. So a lot of people chose to stay because of that. In fact, the people who ended up at UofC likely ranked CMH higher. The problem, CMH has this rule that they only take like 3 northwestern kids every year. In fact, this year our students were so good, they took more than the typical 3.
OB/Gyn
This is my specialty. Prentice Women's hospital is one of the best OB/Gyn programs in the nation. The girl who matched into it, could have gone anywhere in the nation. She did indeed check out the Boston programs as well as UNC and the other top tier OB programs, but she is from chicago, AND our OB/gyn program is is one of the best. (no lie) go through the faculty, all of the heads have pages and pages of publications. The rest all matched at great OB programs. UCSF, Wash U. The guy going to yale is interested in Gyn-Onc and Yale has one of the best gyn-onc programs.
Prelim and transitional years are BS. Don't even look at those lists. People pick based on where they will have the most "chill" year.
Psychiatry
We sent kids into two of the top psych programs in the nation(NYU and columbia). Actually, steph was so great a student, she would have matched well in any specialty she chose. Word on the street, is that the New York programs are the best. Theres a lot of crazies there!
Emergency Medicine
Hmm...I dont know aything about the competitiveness of the EM places other than cook county is great. I do know, that we usually send a steady stream of people to cook County(THE buesiest ER in the nation and the basis for tv's ER). This year we only sent 1, but the year before we sent like 3.
Orthopedics
These guys matched really well. Many of them stayed at Northwestern because its a good program. The ones that did not stay went to better programs. UWash is generally thought of as one of the best ortho progs in the nation, if not the best. HSS is also top tier, but very few people know about it outside of ortho because again, it does not have harvard or anything attached to its name.
General Surgery
This was probably our weakest specialty this year. They did not match at bad programs. However, admittedly, none of these places are Mass gen. Joe phillips probably could have gone to one of those places, however, he has family in chicago and is married so he chose to stay in the city.
Radiology
We have the best radiology program in the city(one can argue that UofC is on par with us). U maryland is also one of the best rads progs in the nation. Butler, interviewed all over the place and eventually decided on UTSW(another top tier rads program). He has family in texas.
I am tired of typing...I will talk about the other specialties later. I will also talk about those that did not match, and why they did not match.
In any case...I think our match list is great this year. Keep in mind, the quality of a school lies in whether it can take you where you want to go. Do not judge our list based on whether we have X amount of mass gen matches. Because I would argue that this year we had quite a few people want to stay in chicago. Many of those people could have, had they wanted to, go to hopkins, mass gen, etc. Nevertheless, our school provides that opportunity.
I shall write about the other specialties later. whew!